Thursday, February 14, 2008

Of Marriages [Part II]

Reading my first post in this series, if you had come to a conclusion that I am in trying to say that love marriage is the best, you are wrong. As I had mentioned in my first post, I am just trying to put forth my views on Indian marriages (or probably south-Indian or more precisely marriages in TamilNadu!). In this post I am laying down my views on love marriages in India.

As I had pointed out in my first post, love marriages provide solution to a lot of issues that arise in the case of arranged marriages. And, in addition, there are more positive points in the case of love marriages - they help us create a caste-less society; and generally there will be no issue of dowry and there is no requirement to verify the details of the spouse [this becomes important as I have heard in recent times - some stories of guys (living abroad) cheating the bride's parents with wrong information about their job or concealing the fact that they are already married]. However, love marriages too have pitfalls. When someone falls in love, everything about his/her lover seems to be good if not great! To tell the fact, both the girl and the boy in love projects the better half of them to the other. The reality strikes only when they start living together. For then, they look at each other from close quarters… In one way arranged marriage is better than love marriage. In arranged marriage there are fewer expectations since the spouse is a total stranger. But in love marriage one has a lot of expectations since he/she knows his/her spouse for a long time. So, when they start to live together, any small deviation from what they had imagined will be a big blow in love marriage. So, all I can say is, "If you love, don't be in a hurry to propose the girl/boy. First get yourself clarified if it is really 'love' or just an attraction. Try to know more about the person before you propose or accept a proposal. If you have the slightest doubt that things could go wrong after marriage, don't propose. And, in case you start loving, don't let your imaginations fly high - till the time you get married and start living together".

My mother once pointed out that in love marriages, things like food habits might cause havoc. I could not comprehend the point she made. Then, my mother explained: Suppose two people from different states love each other. There is very less chance that they might think about the difference in their food habits – before marriage. But, once married, they will start realizing that they cannot adjust with the food their spouse likes. Now, food being a daily issue will indirectly cause problems. At that time, I had less real- life experience to accept that [Actually my immediate thought was (though I did not tell this to my mom!), "I like Punjabi food more than south-Indian food. So do you mean to say that I can love a Punjabi girl?"]. But then, after staying in the hostel and then traveling to different places, I understood the truth in her statement. Though it might seem silly, small things like food do matter really when it comes to living together. Here, arranged marriage helps since generally we choose people who have a similar background as ourselves. So, food and daily habits will be similar if not same as that of ours. This – my mother says – is the reason for people to search alliance at places in and around their hometown.

Another issue about love marriages is the decision made by some lovers to leave their parents for the sake of their love. I do not support such a decision. If people are ready to leave their parents who had played an important role in making them what they are today, then it is highly likely that they may not be true in any of their relationship. Even if they are true to their spouse, there are other issues. There was this guy – a roommate of mine at the college – whose parents had separated from his grandparents (both paternal and maternal) for the sake of their love. He used to say, "As a kid, whenever summer vacations begin, I will see people leaving to their grandparents' house. But I had to stay home since I had no relatives. And, whenever others speak about their grandparents (on returning from vacation), I would simply walk away from that place. I never knew how it would feel having grandparents and other relatives." One might think that leaving their parents would be a good option. But then, by doing that they are depriving their children of what they are entitled to. And, surely they don't have the right to do so. So, all I would say is that, one should try to convince his/her parents to accept their lover. In case it is not possible, I would advice one to do what his/her parents say. This obviously necessitates one to tell their parents of their love at a very early stage.

Considering all those things that I have seen happening around me, I would say that there are several things that require deep thinking before decisions are made in case of a marriage – be it arranged or love marriage. Anyhow, from my point of view, the order of marriage options that might lead to a better married life is (anyhow, this does not mean that I would follow this order as a rule... it all depends on circumstances...):

  1. Conventional love marriage.
  2. Arranged marriage to someone one had known for a long time.
  3. Love marriage where either the girl or the boy had only loved the other person but the other person had no reason to say no to the proposal.
  4. Arranged marriage where the bride is chosen by some good logical means.
  5. Conventional arranged marriage.

Labels: ,

13 Comments:

Blogger Harie said...

"So, all I would say is that, one should try to convince his/her parents to accept their lover."
I would agree to the above statement that they should try to convince but i disagree on the following statement.
"In case it is not possible, I would advice one to do what his/her parents say."
Just because they are not able to convince doesn't mean that they have to do what their parents say.I agree that parents have a say and an opinion but the life is theirs and they should decide what to do by themselves with clarity and should not go by what parents say.This reminds me of a saying "if you don't decide your life some one else will".

This is my view and in no way intended to criticize your view.

Overall a very good post and was waiting for the second post in this topic.As usual you and your posts rock.

Tuesday, February 19, 2008  
Blogger KP said...

A deep analysis.These two posts juz spoken our thoughts..most of these thoughts come from our assumptions and widely accepted theories..Obviously we dont have direct experiences yet..we get these thoughts from what we hear from the gossips ,mega-serials and other desi movies and these assumptions continue to rule our life.

Basically you gave the positives and negatives about love marriages and arranged ones in the aspect of their success rate.
Do we need to measure the success in terms of petty misunderstandings about the food habits ?They can be ignored if you are going to live with a person whom you love.Isnt?

If it is the probability of being happy after marriage,the risk rate is same for arranged marriage,love marriage and no marriage..Life is not driven by equations.Anything can be changed anytime.People change,their priority change.If only we are able to fix it ,we are among the survivors.

It depends on people and their attitude in welcoming changes in the society .If two people love each other ,their kids will miss grandparents love? why it should be? Why cant the grandparents be little more flexible? . I feel , To produce kids without love is worser than depriving them of grandparents love.

In short my vote is only for love marriage because arranged marriages dont make any sense to me.

Tuesday, February 19, 2008  
Blogger akp said...

@Harie
Actually I wrote that just to make a mention that one needs to think well before taking decisions (meaning, I agree with your point). It all depends on the actual situation. Also, one must realize that if one keeps doing what he/she likes - without considering the various consequences of such moves (or without any consideration to people around), one might become more self-centric.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008  
Blogger akp said...

@KP
Actually, the underlying point that I wanted to say is that,

1. There are many issues that have to be given a thought when it comes to marriage.

2. It is better to marry a known person than a total stranger so that one atleast knows what to expect and what not to expect - to some extent.

So, I agree with what you say. Those examples that I had given were mainly to highlight the various issues that one might possibly come across through the way of marriage and the solutions to the problems of course depends on the exact situation, the people involved and their way of thinking.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008  
Blogger Unknown said...

hi anna.. it made a good read.. am not going to critically analyse the article u hav put up ( cos i cant do)..
but i wanna know a few things.. the article was put up on feb 14.. is it jus a co incidence or intentional.. and one good way to find a bride for u.. ask her to read ur blogs.. if she finds it good then proceed :) :) :)

Thursday, March 13, 2008  
Blogger akp said...

@Raajay
It was unintentionally intentional... ;) Actually, there is an option to set any date we want for a post... I used that option...

Monday, March 17, 2008  
Blogger Blade bala said...

Good post akp! Pinnitteenga!

Vazhakkam poela namma kp avanga kodiya nattuttu poittaanga!

Adding to your statement on living in close quarters, I think marriage is all about two people living inside four walls and making those four walls a home (ceiling illiyaannu kaekka koodaadhu, aamaa!!!). A lot of people think that petty differences can be kept aside. Saying it is easier than doing it. For example, if you like non-veg food and your spouse hates it then you really cannot enjoy your food, or even cannot go to the same restaurant and enjoy the food of your likes. So, I think if you list down what you are ready to forego and not forego in the event of differences, then it makes it easier. In other words, it would be better if you know what you can tolerate and what you cannot tolerate. This might sound like a negative approach, but this can make marriages positive. I think this is what is summarised as give and take, and these days it is a two-way road and be ready to give if you also want to take something.

Friday, August 15, 2008  
Blogger akp said...

@Blade Bala:

"A lot of people think that petty differences can be kept aside" - highly true.

"So, I think if you list down what you are ready to forego and not forego in the event of differences, then it makes it easier." - here again I agree. Also, to add up to your point, I would say that newly married people should not hesitate to speak to their partner about what they really like and what they don't. People might think that they can keep some of the things to themselves. This might lead to problems in the long run. Whereas speaking out can help reach an amicable solution (of course one of them would have to "adjust" for the other one's sake!).

Saturday, August 16, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

AKP...All of your so called Intellectual way of approaching this is definitely not going to address this simple issue. We need to understand that core values and stuff are that which we make for ourself. And the joy of marriage is to Agree to Disagree, as the probability of finding a partner with whom you get along on all fronts from day 1 is almost 0, and the whole concept of PERFECT match is absolute crap. Its very simple - Humanity and human values demand that every person learns to live with every other person. And love as projected in films and magazines has no meaning. Real love is Love for Humanity and there is nothing else.

If you want to complicate marriage with so many approaches and priorities, i would rather dump you as a philospher who cannot relate to the problems of the world. And by complicating things like this, Most of the human population is gonna stay UN-MARRIED or Married tooo late in life..Both of this has related social problems (i dont need to explain that )...
Pls read established religious scriputures and you will find Divine Wisdom, which when analyzed with commaon sense makes REAL SENSE.

AND BE A RESPONSIBLE CITIZEN by not confusing people with your thoughts...

would love to explain in detail, but not time..lol

Anyway...SPEND ur time directing you thoughts to CONSTRUCTIVE task and dont waste ur time buddy.

Thursday, September 17, 2009  
Blogger akp said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

Thursday, September 17, 2009  
Blogger akp said...

@Anonymous: A true comment atlast... I guess this is the one of those very rare comments that I receive... I mean most of the people who leave comments generally keep their true views to themselves... and try not to annoy the writer... By the way, answering your comment, I would say, "Views differ... you have yours and I have mine... and, considering the percentage of the fellow citizens who read this blog, I dont see any irresponsible act of a citizen... And, even if so, everyone has the rights to voice their views (or confuse people as you put it!) in a democratic country - I believe :)"


Anyhow, I would have loved to know who you are... could not connect you to any of my usual readers... your style of writing and views do not seem to match any of those usual visitors... !

Thursday, September 17, 2009  
Blogger Dhanabalan..Shortly Dhana said...

Hey Buddy, every point of yours makes perfect logical sense. But one factor that is missing is 'Love'. The human body is made up of various parts.The Brain obviously helps in analyzing things and doing rational things. But there are various other things in our body, say for example 'harmones', that impact what we feel, and what we do. If you keep the logical thinking aside, even just pure love for the other person, can help you sort out various problems and differences.So while i do agree with your view, all I am saying is , there are more things to it, than just compatiblity, clash of core ideals, etc, for leading a successful married life (The term 'successful' itself is debatable, but in my definition, a relationship is successful, if both of you have the complete confidence, that the other person is there for you,however difficult the circumstances are, and can understand what you need in that difficult situation and provide the support you need).

Thursday, February 11, 2010  
Blogger akp said...

Thanks for dropping by my blog... and, I agree with you...!

Its nearly two years since I wrote this blog post... and, this two years have taught something about what you say!

:)

Thursday, February 11, 2010  

Post a Comment

<< Home